Take the 2-minute tour ×
Linguistics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for professional linguists and others with an interest in linguistic research and theory. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In English, a 'gasp' exclamation seems to be the only word spoken while inhaling. Though it is sometimes implied that the expression is not voluntary, it typically is in most conversations.

I was curious though, are there other languages and cultures that actually speak more complex words while inhaling? It seems entirely possible, even if the articulation is somewhat limited. Does anyone know of any examples?

share|improve this question
3  
There are several varieties of ingressive sounds. Click consonants use ingressive mouth air and voiced implosives use ingressive throat air. The Swedish backchannel conversational marker (equivalent to English "uh huh") is a breathy vowel with ingressive lung air. –  jlawler Mar 11 at 20:10
    
Note that the OP is asking specifically about speaking while inhaling, which would technically limit the relevant answers to pulmonic ingressive sounds. Several of the answers below are therefore not directly relevant. –  musicallinguist Mar 12 at 12:27
    
I wonder whether the OP was deliberately meaning to include only pulmonic ingressive sounds, or ehtehr "while inhaling" was a more loose term indicating air going inwards rather than outwards? –  GreenAsJade Mar 12 at 13:32
2  
The mischief in me wants to suggest Tenacious D's 'inward singing' youtube.com/watch?v=HeKx6EuMZWM&feature=kp (caution, may contain rude words) –  yochannah Mar 12 at 15:14

5 Answers 5

up vote 13 down vote accepted

Yes, in such a case you'd be talking about Ingressive sounds (the air flows in), whereas most languages are typically egressive (the air flows out).

It occurs in Scandinavian languages, sometimes in English (the gasp you talked about), Brazilian Portuguese. As stated in the article:

Speech technologist Robert Eklund (http://roberteklund.info) has found reports of ingressive speech in around 50 languages worldwide, dating as far back as Cranz's (1765) "Historie von Grönland, enthaltend… " where it is mentioned in female affirmations among the Eskimo.

You will find more concrete examples in the page linked above.

share|improve this answer
2  
Yes, in certain southern dialects of Norwegian the standard word for yes ja is pronounced with ingressive pulmonic air. My linguistic textbooks considered those sounds edge cases and I don't believe they've been found in wide use (besides a handful of phonemes) in any language. –  sventechie Mar 12 at 1:04
    
@sventechie Yes, some of these examples seem not to be widely used, but I wanted to share some of them here in order to avoid leaving the answer without any information at all. If you feel like it, we can further expand my answer to treat each case more in depth, albeit briefly, in order to present a more accurate answer. :) –  Alenanno Mar 12 at 9:20
    
I think your answer is good. But it is worth noting that since they only occur in 2--5 words per language and never contrastively (e.g., there is no egressive word ja in Norwegian that means something else) they are not considered phonemes. I'd be interested if there are polysyllabic words spoken ingressively, since all the Scandinavian words (ja, nej, ju, etc.) I know of are monosyllabic. Any ideas? –  sventechie Mar 16 at 23:44

There's another sound "in English" which is usually written as "tsk" which is the sound you make when you when indicating disapproval (tsk-tsk-tsk). So "gasp" is not the only ingressive sound used by English speakers :)

share|improve this answer
2  
This is true, but the 'tsk' sound is not a pulmonic ingressive (i.e., it is not created by inhaling), so it is not directly relevant for the OP's question. –  musicallinguist Mar 12 at 12:34
    
Oh interesting. I never realized I was inhaling when saying "tsk", but it turns out I am! –  coffeematt Mar 12 at 18:12
2  
@user3281 you're not! You're creating a vacuum with your tongue, which causes the air to rush inward when you release it. But you can convince yourself that you're not inhaling by exhaling through your nose while making the 'tsk' sound. –  musicallinguist Mar 12 at 18:23

In Icelandic, people often say the word "yes" (já) while inhaling. But like in the examples of Swedish and Norwegian, this is a special case.

share|improve this answer
1  
Likewise for Finnish joo. This seems to be a Scandinavian areal feature. –  TKR Mar 12 at 4:08
1  
Danish too, since it's being left out. –  dainichi Mar 12 at 6:57

There are also the so called "click languages" of Africa. (The movie "The Gods Must Be Crazy" features a lot of it) The only ones I can name off the top of my head are !Xoon and !Kung.

  • They are also the only languages I know of where characters we use as punctuation are used as actual phonemes. E.G. "!" is an actual sound in !kung. It's a sound I can describe, but can't seem to wrap my mouth around. Basically do a tongue click against the roof of your mouth and blend into the x sound as in fox or box. This requires air ingress, but just into the throat, followed by an egress, again, just the air within mouth and throat, little lung action at all.

  • share|improve this answer
    1  
    "Characters" are not "phonemes". I think you have confused language and script. –  fdb Mar 12 at 10:05
        
    Clicks are lingual ingressives (i.e., the inward airflow is created by tongue movement as opposed to inhalation), so they are not directly relevant for the OP's question. –  musicallinguist Mar 12 at 12:33

    The above-mentioned Wikipedia articles “ingressive sounds” and “implosive consonant” are not too bad as descriptions of the sounds concerned, but are not very comprehensive in their enumeration of the languages affected. They fail (for example) to mention that one major language, namely Vietnamese, has implosive ɓ and ɗ (orthographic b and đ) as part of its phonological system.

    share|improve this answer
    2  
    Note, though, that implosive consonants are not pulmonic implosives (i.e., they are not produced by inhaling), so Vietnamese wouldn't be directly relevant for the OP's question. –  musicallinguist Mar 12 at 12:31

    Your Answer

     
    discard

    By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

    Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.