I am a little confused about what affix to add first to the stem "elect". The word is re-election. If I add the suffix -ion first, then it turns the verb into a noun. The affix 're-' attaches best to verbs (if I'm not mistaken). Should I just attach the prefix first then?

  • 1
    If re- can be added to the verbs that the nouns come from, then they can appear on the nouns that are derived from them. Re-elect is a verb, so re-election is the derived noun. Mar 19 '15 at 17:27
  • so it doesnt matter which one i add first? or i could check in a corpus which on is the most common? Mar 19 '15 at 17:32
  • 1
    Re- is a verbal prefix. The re- appears on the verb. And the verb gets made into a noun. There's no "first" -- this isn't what happens when you talk, it's what happened when the verb was borrowed from Latin. Mar 19 '15 at 17:35

The first test you should apply is whether re- can be added to a noun and give another noun – *re-tree, *re-pig and so on should persuade you that re- does not attach to nouns. Second is to verify that re- attaches to verb, e.g. re-take, re-think, re-elect. Then when faced with a derivation from noun to verb or verb to noun, if on the surface you find a word of one category X which takes an affix that only attaches to category Y, and if the word also has an affix that converts a Y to an X, then you should assume that the restricted affix is added to the category Y stem first, and then Y changes to X.

Words like "first", "then" are used by linguists in different ways — either literally, meaning in time (i.e. there is a claim about processing) or else in terms of lower versus higher levels of attachment in a structural tree (in case you want to avoid any implications about processing). To really put your theory to the test, you should also try to find newly-generated forms, like "re-macadamize" or even "re-pre-macadamize", which can't reasonably be accused of being historical archaisms (unless you build roads for a living). "Re-think" is a good example since unlike re-elect, it couldn't have been pre-constructed in Latin.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.