0

For example, adding -ly to quick to make quickly. Or adding -ly to gentleman to make gentlemanly.

  • Evidence for word class of what, of the base? – Ivan Kapitonov Oct 9 '15 at 0:13
  • I think both. Like "he is quick" is correct but "he is quickly" is not. But this feels like syntactic evidence – Kimmy Oct 9 '15 at 0:16
  • Well yes, these last two examples show that adverbs can't be predicative in English. You need to edit your question to clarify what the problem specifically is. – Ivan Kapitonov Oct 9 '15 at 0:18
  • -ly makes adverb – Anixx Oct 9 '15 at 5:58
2

Since -ly can be affixed to nouns (gentlemanly, friendly, ghostly, spritely) and adjectives (unlikely, quickly, heavily, lightly), but not to verbs, then it isn't much use as a diagnostic of word class. It also doesn't doesn't combine with "house" or "yellow", so in case you were looking for an argument than "run" is a verb, the fact that you don't get *runly isn't even proof that run is a verb, since there are also simple gaps in what nouns and adjectives combine with -ly.

| improve this answer | |
1

It does not provide evidence but it certainly narrows thing down. -ly attaches to nouns and adjectives. It tends to turn nouns into adjectives coward > cowardly, gentleman > gentlemanly and adjectives into adverbs quick > quickly.

But there are exceptions such as like > likely - here it is hard to determine whether like is a verb, noun or adjective but 'likely' is itself an adjective. Of course, due to the flexibility of English in its use of different word classes in other contexts, adjectives are often used as nouns. For instance, 'daily' which is often used as a noun when referring to newspapers or 'elderly' in 'take care of the elderly' or 'friendly' as in 'they played a friendly at Wimbledom'.

Of course, there are also many words that end in '-ly' where it does not indicate a suffix 'family', 'monopoly', 'Italy', 'monopoly'. Or it's not clear on the surface if it's a suffix, such as 'assembly' or it's definitely not a suffix but it looks like one as in 'folly'.

The best way to find out more is to go to a corpus and search for -ly on words with different parts of speech. Try BNC with search terms such as *ly.[n*], *ly.[j*], *ly.[r*].

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.