3

As we know the ToBI system is designed to transcribe prosody and within it you can transcribe only High and Low prosody changes. The question is here Why don't we implement frequency change and/or duration in ToBI system?

For instance we can add numerical value (like 50H%) to show that the H in this utterance is +50 Hz.

My questions are:

  1. Is it plausible?
  2. Is there any use in doing so?
1
  • 1
    As in your previous question, the point seems to be: that’s not what ToBI is for. In the same way that phonemic transcription doesn’t specify subphonemic variation in an utterance, ToBI is not intended to deal with incidental variation in pitch/duration. If there’s a systematic prosodic distinction between the higher and lower versions, then they’d get different symbols. – Jeremy Needle Jan 13 '16 at 18:29
2

The basic idea of ToBI comes from the work of English intonationalist in the 70's, especially Liberman and Pierrehumbert, operating within an autosegmental phonological framework. The stipulation that you have only H and L in Tobi is for the most part an arbitrary stipulation, and there is nothing wrong with positing M as a tonal element (as Liberman did). The strongest reason for not including "M" is that it is not necessary. And I should point out that ToBI is more an "approach" than a formal theory, so there is no specific principle prohibiting the addition of other categories.

However, the nature of ToBI is that it is a system for talking about categories, and not continua. Thus expanding ToBI to have numeric operators in the representation would totally change what ToBI is. You could do that, but then it would not be ToBI, it would be a new system. Similarly, ToBI is about pitch, and it isn't a general theory of all of prosody. Again, you could construct a new system that is intended to express durational properties, but then you should call it something else -- perhaps DuBI (Du for "duration).

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.