Linguistics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for professional linguists and others with an interest in linguistic research and theory. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this community
In phones, you now can use speech to do VAD (Voice Activated Dialing). As in, "Call Bob". This works fine in isolating languages.
I was told that in Polish (pl-PL), it is more natural to say "Call Dawida" when the name is Dawid.
In languages that decline given names, how strange is it to say "Call Dawid" when talking to a phone?
I don't know how the phone system works in Poland, and besides that's a question for a telephony user group or something, not a linguistics question. So I will address the linguistic point.
Many languages other than English have a case system for marking the grammatical roles of words like nouns. In most instances this also applies to proper nouns like personal names. Case-marking in Polish takes the form of suffixes that are appended to the base form of the word. For the masculine name Dawid, the forms are:
Nominative Dawid = David as a subject
Accusative Dawida = David as a direct object, to David
Dative Dawidowi = David as an indirect object, to/for David
Genitive Dawida = David's, of David
Instrumental Dawidem = with/by David
Locative Dawidzie = at/on/to David
Vocative Dawidzie = O David!
Apart from that, there exist prepositions, as English to, from etc. The verb (za)dzwonić 'call' takes the preposition do 'to' which requires the genitive, so the whole phrase is (za)dzwoń do Dawida 'call to David-Gen.'.
Commenters above are right in pointing out that the question is not entirely linguistic, but since it's already been asked and the linguistic part answered, I'll complete it with the non-linguistic bit.
It's very uncommon for people in Poland to use VAD. It's not really faster than choosing the person from the list and is usually considered showing off, sort of like using a mobile in the early nineties. But whenever anyone does use it, the phones usually let them record their own call, so they end saying (za)dzwoń do Dawida, or just simply Dawid. (The za- bit is aspect; with it, it's perfective, without it, it's imperfective. In this particular situation both can be used.)
I will admit, however, that I did see a good couple of years ago someone say zadzwoń Dawid. I presume his phone required the call and David bits to be recorded separately, and he preferred to say zadzwoń Dawid than zadzwoń Dawida because somehow it seems less ungrammatical, and he simply didn't think of recording do Dawida for 'David'.
