-1

A שד (pronounced shade) is a demon or ghost, in Hebrew. In English, the word 'shade' is used to mean ghost or demon in some places. (I find it in fantasy novels a lot.)

Is there any relation?

4
9

Probably not.

The etymology of English "shade" (newest to oldest) is something like:

  • Modern English "shade"
  • Old English sċeadu (shadow)
  • Proto-Germanic *skađwaz (shadow)
  • Proto-Indo-European *sk(e)h₃-tos (darkness)

There's decent evidence for this being a native Indo-European root; while it was most productive in Germanic, it has descendants in different parts of the world as well (Ancient Greek σκότος/skótos, Irish scáth, loaned into Finnish katve).

The main etymology of Hebrew šed that I've found is:

  • Modern Hebrew šed (spirit)
  • Aramaic šēḏā (demon)
  • Akkadian šēdu (a male lamassu (protective zodiac deity))
  • (Unknown preceding Proto-Semitic form - but see fdb's answer)

(Transcribing all of these because my computer does not like changing text direction mid-line.)

There doesn't seem to be any obvious connection between *sk(e)h₃-tos and šēdu, in form or in meaning. This is more likely just a coincidence.

2
  • 2
    Hmm. Well, that's a pretty good coincidence.
    – Mithical
    Jan 9 '17 at 17:57
  • 8
    @Mithrandir Linguistic coincidences are legion. They happen all the time. For that reason, the default position when encountering a linguistic coincidence is to treat it as just that: coincidental, and nothing more, until such time as evidence is produced to make a concrete connection. In other words, when you hit a coincidence, either ignore it or see what the already-established etymologies have to say (as Draconis has done here in their answer).
    – Dan Bron
    Jan 9 '17 at 18:57
3

Akkadian šēdu is probably cognate with Arabic saʽd “happiness”. Aramaic šēδā and Hebrew šēδ are most probably borrowings from Akkadian, with reversal of the meaning (“good spirit” > “pagan god” > “evil spirit”).The proto-Semitic form would then be *s1aʽd.

http://dukhrana.com/lexicon//lookup.php?p=748&l=0

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.