I have a phrase and I have to draw a tree structure of it.

"These many awful photographs" is the phrase.

The only thing that I don't get is the "many".
"These" is DP, "awful" is the adjective, and "photograph" is the noun.

I guess "many" is a determiner, but how I should indicate it?

And where in the structure the post determiners fit? I guess it's the adjunct right and not a specifier or complementer?

  • 1
    "These" and "many" belong to the category 'determinative' and their function here is 'determiner'. "Awful" is of course an adjective whose function is 'modifier'. The end result is Det-Det-Adj-N for categories, and D-D-M-H for functions. – BillJ Apr 27 '17 at 11:16

This is not a general answer to the title question, because the "determinative" (in Cambridge GEL terminology; or "determiner" in Comprehensive GEL terminology) word class seems to be heterogeneous and have a number of significant subdivisions.

"Many" can be classified as a quantifier or with the term you use in your question, "post-determiner" (which I found explained more in the blog post "Exploring determiners").

In the specific case of "These many awful photographs", I would say many does not function syntactically as a "determiner" (in Cambridge GEL terminology; or "determinative" in Comprehensive GEL terminology); rather, it is adjectival.

I did find a statement that supports this in "Chapter 2: Categories" of A Grammar of English Gelderen 2000, which says

Finally, quantifiers are adjectival, as in the many problems and in (34) [...]

  1. The challenges are many/few.

However, I don't know if this is a simplification, so I might be wrong about this.

It essentially means the same thing as "numerous," another word that can be a quantifier, but that clearly has adjective morphology (the suffix -ous) and that seems to also be able to be used as an adjective. As evidence that the word many can be adjectival when it comes in this post-determiner position, consider its coordination with adjectives in phrases like "these many and complex causes" or "these many and great dangers". According to "Beyond Syntactic Change: various and numerous" by Tine Breban, there is a claim made by Bache (1978) that coordination between adnominal modifiers is only possible if they have the same grammatical function.

Of course, in your example, there is no coordination, so this argument, if correct, would only show that "many" could be adjectival in this position, not that it has to be.

If it is adjectival, it would indeed be an adjunct according to the theories of grammar that I am familar with. The blog post "Of adjectives and adjuncts" by Paul Hagstrom says

Adjectives are modifiers, like adverbs are. So, the way they attach is with Adjoin.

Another description of adjectives as adjuncts is available from the XTAG Project page "Adjectives".

| improve this answer | |
  • Can someone explain me how the tree structure of "these many awful photographs" looks like please? Thanks for the answers! – Anna Varga Apr 25 '17 at 19:44

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.