1

Are there are IPA symbols which are the subject of some controversy? For example, I suppose there are some who would like to have a unitary"tS" t-esh sound as a unitary phoneme... but I bet there are loads of other examples. I'd really like to learn about any ongoing/resolved discussions about IPA symbols... Thanks!

enter image description here

2
  • 2
    All IPA (or other transcriptional) symbols are subject to some controversy. Introduction of any new IPA symbol, or modification of existing ones, are by definition controversial. One can say that the "meaning" of every IPA symbol is somewhat controversial. Are you asking "what does it take to get a symbol added to the IPA"?
    – user6726
    Jul 10 '17 at 15:50
  • Vote to close: this question is too broad.
    – CJ Dennis
    Jul 10 '17 at 23:19
5

Oh yes, very much so! The IPA is constantly changing and expanding, and existing symbols are moved, repurposed, and deleted. Many linguists still use the "Americanist" system, for instance, which prefers diacritics to new symbols (/š/ instead of /ʃ/) and single symbols (like /č/) for affricates.

To give a few other examples:

  • Some people like affricates being written as two separate symbols, but others prefer to give them their own symbols (since they're often phonemic). So as a compromise there used to be ligature letters like /ʧ/ and /ʦ/.
  • Until 1895, /q/ was used for the voiced velar fricative. It was then replaced with "g with a loop" (as opposed to loopless /ɡ/), and then with "g with a bar", before finally becoming the modern gamma /ɣ/.
  • Until 1989, clicks were written with Latin-like letters /ʇ ʗ ʖ/ rather than /ǀ ǃ ǁ/. This was a subject of significant debate, which affected some languages' orthographies.
  • By analogy, /ʞ/ was proposed for a velar click. In 1970 the IPA changed their minds and said that a velar click was impossible, and removed the symbol. But now some linguists suggest that it's possible and found in some languages; the debate is ongoing.

For more examples, see Wikipedia's summary.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.