1

I've seen linguistics arguing in favour of using either ɪ/ʊ or j/w sets in glides offset. What are your arguments regarding the use of them?

8
  • 1
    Related: Why is the “long i” sound in English written /aɪ/? In the context of English phonemic transcriptions, I don't see that it particularly matters which one you use, unless someone else is demanding that your transcriptions conform to some specified format for some reason. If you are interested in how these symbols are used in other contexts, it would help if you could specify what languages and types of transcription you are asking about. Mar 20 '18 at 2:20
  • Kenyon and Knott used /ɪ/ to mark the final syllable in easy, though most American linguists continue to transcribe (and pronounce) it as /i/. The issue doesn't arise for /ʊ/, because American phonemic practice doesn't transcribe the diphthongized tense vowels, instead using single vowel symbols and relegating the automatic glides to allomorphy, not represented phonemically. Plus, of course, American English /o/ isn't centralized to /əʊ/ like RP.
    – jlawler
    Mar 20 '18 at 2:35
  • Thank you for your comments. I don't feel like using ɪ and ʊ in glides offset because I don't pronounce them like that. I don't pronounce "may" as [meɪ] or "south" as [saʊθ] if we consider the real sound of ɪ and ʊ. I can't even pronounce that. But there are people who are against the use of j and w because they'd be consonant sounds. In the case of the word "easy" or words ending with "-ly", the RP transcription is [i], but it's pronounced as a diphthong [ɪj] for many people in England and even as [ɪ] in old-fashioned posh RP. Mar 20 '18 at 12:36
  • What is your basis for claiming that you don't pronounce the off-glides "like that" – i.e. what is your standard of comparison?
    – user6726
    Mar 20 '18 at 15:00
  • We have the same kind of dyphthongs in Portuguese and we don't pronounce the sound ɪ in these diphthongs, even though they are represented with this symbol by many linguists. If I try to pronounce these diphthongs with that sound, it sounds really odd. Mar 21 '18 at 1:09

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.