4

The verb "keep" can be used with a direct object and a prepositional phrase, as in the following sentence:

He kept a black book in his desk.

What is the grammatical role of the PP "in his desk"? Is it an adverbial adjunct, or is it a complement? (Or is it some third thing?) Semantically, it seems to describe the location of the direct object, so the meaning seems consistent with its being an "object complement". However, my first thought was that it was an adverbial adjunct.

I found a list of tests for finding out if something is an adjunct or a complement on the following page: "XBar Theory: Complements and adjuncts", Linguistics 522, Jean Mark Gawron, San Diego State University. But even after going through them, I'm not sure if "in his desk" is an adjunct or a complement here.

My attempt at applying the tests:

  • Order: an adjunct cannot come between a head and a complement. The examples are in noun phrases, not verb phrases. The direct object "a black book" is not an adjunct, so this test is not applicable to the original sentence. I guess the sentence could be altered to make the test applicable if I tried to add an adjunct before "in his desk":

  • Do-so replacement: "do so" can replace V's (using the terminology of X-bar theory). I'm not sure whether "Dan kept a black book in his desk, and Sally did so in her bag" is ungrammatical: it sounds bad to me, but "Dan kept a black book, and Sally did so also" also sounds bad, and that second sentence doesn't even have any prepositional phrases involved.

  • Coordination: it's ungrammatical to coordinate a complement with an adjunct. "He kept a black book in his desk and despite my advice" doesn't seem right to me, but I'm not sure if this is strong evidence that "in his desk" is a complement.

  • Preposing: Apparently, "verbs dont like having their complement PPs preposed". This test seems to point towards "in his desk" being an adjunct, because "In his desk, he kept a black book" seems acceptable and grammatical to me.

Araucaria's answer to "Is this Adverbial a complement or an adjunct?" on ELU seems to say that an adverbial adjunct should be equally acceptable if a verb and direct object are replaced with "do it", giving the example "They played football in the park / They did it in the park". This suggests to me that "in his desk" is not an adjunct, because we can't say "He did it in his desk" to mean "He kept a black book in his desk".

Have I been interpreting these tests correctly? Are there any other tests I should be using?

  • I go along with H&P and call it not a PC but a locative complement. In your example, "keep" is transitive with "a black book" as O. The PP "in the drawer" thus has O-orientation. – BillJ May 31 '18 at 19:18
  • The possibility of modifying the object+complement combo with a duration adverb suggests to me that it is not an adjunct: "He kept a black book in his desk for decades" implies the book remained in his desk for decades, not that he kept putting the book there, over and over. – Greg Lee May 31 '18 at 19:36
  • Another good test is eliding the object (removing the possibility of an object complement): "He kept in his desk" changes the meaning, so "in his desk" is not an adjunct in the original. – amI Apr 8 '19 at 5:58
1

[1] He kept it handy.

[2] He kept it in the drawer.

Briefly, Huddleston & Pullum in CGEL pp. 257-8, note that there is a structural similarity between the predicative complement in [1] and the locative complement in [2], which suggests that assigning a location to something is comparable to assigning it a property.

They argue that one respect in which locative complements resemble predicatives is that they too are oriented towards either the subject in intransitives (The letter is on the table), or the object in transitives, as in [2].

They go on to say that, however, since there are numerous verbs which only take one or the other (PC or locative), they do not assimilate the locatives to the predicatives, but regard them as syntactically distinct kinds of complements that exhibit certain semantic resemblances.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.