0

I've checked several dictionaries for the word "stolen" only to find it labeled a verb. Virtually all of the examples sentences use it in a manner that I would have considered an adjective:

"The stolen property was confiscated."

The dictionaries use the past participle of steal as the sole part of speech, which seems incorrect. Am I missing something?

  • 1
    It depends on which linguist you ask, but many would consider this to be an 'adjectival passive' or 'lexical passive', in which case it's still the (verbal) PP of 'steal'. – WavesWashSands Jul 10 '18 at 2:09
  • @WavesWashSands that seems like an answer to me. – OmarL Jul 18 '18 at 14:06
5

As Greg Lee indicates, participles are commonly considered to remain verbs, despite being used "like adjectives" in many cases.

However, the situation is a bit confusing because, as far as I know, all linguists recognize that participle forms sometimes represent actual adjectives, not verbs. Greg Lee's answer mentioned the "very" test, which indicates that in sentences like "I was very excited about the event" or "He had very swollen feet", the words "excited" and "swollen" are adjectives, despite being identical in form to participles. There are various terms for adjectives of this form; e.g. "participial adjectives" or "departicipial adjectives".

There are a number of tests for distinguishing "participles" (verb forms) and "departicipial adjectives", but different tests don't always agree with each other, and they usually only apply in very specific contexts. As far as I know, there is no way to show that "stolen" is either a verb or an adjective in that sentence. (There seems to be some disagreement in the literature about whether verbal participles can occur in prenominal/attributive position--see my answer to Is “running” a gerund or a participial adjective?--but to me, it seems like they can, so I don't think the position of "stolen" disambiguates its part of speech in "stolen property".)

Looking over the comments beneath my answer there, I just noticed that "carefully" is alleged to only work before participles, not before adjectives. So it seems we can be sure that the word "stolen" would be a participle in a phrase like "the carefully stolen property". But the word "carefully" does not occur in your sentence in its original form, so I'm not sure that the "carefully" test gives us a conclusive answer for your exact sentence.

The existence of the word "unstolen" suggests that "stolen" can sometimes be an adjective, because the negative prefix "un-" typically does not attach to verbs (the homonymous "reversative" prefix "un-" does attach to verbs, but "unstolen" means "not stolen"; it isn't derived from some verb "unsteal"). Based on what I've read, "stolen" would also be considered to be an adjective in contexts like "seem(s) stolen".

| improve this answer | |
  • 2
    In the original Latin grammar that we take our Parts of Speech from, "participle" was its own POS, but "adjective" was not even on the list. In Latin, there were a number of participles with very complex grammar, but adjectives were distinguishable from nouns only by being without intrinsic gender; otherwise they behaved exactly like nouns, and the Latin grammarians called them nouns. – jlawler Jul 10 '18 at 22:14
3

Participles are verbs, not adjectives. Test for verbs by modifying with "very", which doesn't modify verbs, but does modify adjectives.

(But sometimes "adjective" is misleadingly used to mean "modifier of noun", and in that sense, both present and past participles can be counted as adjectives.)

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.