2

Does specifier mean "the" and "possesser" and determiner mean "the" and "possessive 's"?

  • 'Specifier' is just another name for 'determiner'. – BillJ Apr 7 at 10:55
6

Determiner is a grammatical category for words like "the" and "a." Some theories claim that possessive 's is also a determiner.

Specifier is a grammatical relation in certain theories, such as X-bar theory. Determiners are frequently considered specifiers of nouns, although there are some people who follow the "DP-hypothesis" that the determiners are the heads, and nouns are the complements (another grammatical relation).

| improve this answer | |
4

The term specifier denotes a set position in a fixed schema, the X-bar schema. In contrast, the term determiner denotes a specific word category. The next illustration is from Wikipedia (X-bar theory):

enter image description here

The spec marks the specifier position. Often, a determiner occupies the specifier position (in the event that one is dealing with a noun phrase). Thus, in a noun phrase such as the discussion of politics, the determiner the occupies the specifier position and can hence also be viewed as a specifier. The possessive forms my, your, his, her, etc. are determiners like the definite article the, which means they also occupy the specifier position in noun phrases and can therefore also be viewed as specifiers.

In general, though, the X-bar schema is viewed as valid for all phrase categories, so in the event that one has, say, a clause at hand (instead of a noun phrase), the subject is positioned in the specifier position. Thus, an entire phrase can be viewed as a specifier.

Indeed, possessive 's can be viewed as the head of a determiner phrase, whereby it is then the entire phrase that is deemed to be a specifier. For instance, Wilma's, my uncle's, the person we met's, etc. are all headed by 's and can therefore be viewed as determiner phrases. It is these phrases that occupy the specifier position in the schema, not just 's alone.

In sum, the term specifier is a broader term than determiner insofar as a number of distinct word categories and even entire phrases can occupy the specifier position in the schema and hence be viewed as specifiers.

| improve this answer | |
  • Thank you for the diagram. – jlawler Apr 6 at 18:23

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy