I recently saw this image comparing different first person plural masc. pronouns to Pokémon. For reference the pronouns listed are

  • Nosaltres (Cat. Central)

  • Natros (Tortosí)

  • Moatros (Val. Central)

  • Naltres (Lleidatà)

  • Noltros (Malloquí)

  • Mosatros (Val. Meridional)

  • Naltros (Tarragoni)

  • Natres (Ribagorçà)

This seemed neat because the only one of these I had ever heard of was Nosaltres, so I went to learn more. Asside from Nosaltres for which it is easy to find attestation, I was able to find attestation for:

  • mosatros, moatros and natros without citation in a wikipedium claiming they are variants used in Valencian. This matches, but is less specific, than the descriptions in the image. For posterity it says:

    Several variations for nosaltres, vosaltres ('we, you'): mosatros, moatros, natros; vosatros, voatros, vatros; also for the weak form mos/-mos instead of standard ens/-nos ('us').

  • All versions in the image plus some extras in this forum discussion (this site is in Catalán), but this is super informal and not very informative. It does tell me that these pronouns, apart from Nosaltres, are probably considered colloquial.

  • All versions in the image plus some extras in IECat's Diccionari Català-Valencià-Balear (site is in Catalán). It verifies that these regional variations exists and gives some rather strange example sentences.

At this point though I can't find any more. It seems that these variations (plus some more) do exist but that's about it. I would love, though, to be reading more about these, their histories. In particular which changes happened first or second and which forms diverged from each other. Ideally I would like to be able to make a sort of tree or something like that.

Are there any more informative and scholarly resources about the history of the first person plural pronouns in Catalán dialects? I would suppose that these changes would be a part of larger phenomena ongoing in these languages, so a source does not need to specifically reference this word if it clearly applies. I would prefer sources in English or Castilian when possible, but I can read Catalán very slowly.

  • 3
    The distribution is given in the long paragraph that begins with “Fon.” (i.e., pronunciation). They start off giving pronunciations for nosaltres, then say that these are literary forms that aren’t often used in spoken Catalan and that the actually used forms vary by dialect, many dialects having multiple commonly heard forms in free competition or variation. Then they give all the phonetic variants they have collected (in sort of pseudo-IPA) followed by which locations each pronunciation is attested for. – Janus Bahs Jacquet Apr 10 at 23:45
  • 1
    @JanusBahsJacquet "the forms with initial m- have taken that over from the 1pl ending -mos" -- that seems rather implausible IMO (though admittedly I don't have a better explanation). – TKR Apr 11 at 0:37
  • 1
    @TKR Why is that implausible? The same thing has happened in Irish for example, and in a slightly different way also Sanskrit (if memory serves, with the final -m of ahám being from the secondary 1sg ending -m). – Janus Bahs Jacquet Apr 11 at 0:42
  • 2
    Another possibility is that the initial no- developed an on-glide nwo- (as it did in Spanish nuestro), and there was then a fusion [nw] > [m]. – TKR Apr 11 at 2:51
  • 2
    @vectory: First-person plural pronouns are not interrogative. German "mir" is thought to be from coalescence of a preceding verb-final nasal with the "w" of "wir": a recent, not an old development. – brass tacks Apr 11 at 16:10

The following isogloss map from L’Atles Lingüístic del Domini Català details the different pronunciations by region:

enter image description here

| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    Any idea what the raised L for 118 means? I’m guessing it means the L is weakened somehow, but I can’t figure out what the comment for 118 means… (Also, what’s up with the stress marks being in the middle of the syllable? That’s weird IPA’ing.) – Janus Bahs Jacquet Apr 13 at 17:04

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.