I'm aware that it's spellt with an X, however phonetically it's [ks]. According to the SSP, plosives should come after fricatives word-finally. Does the spelling with an x stop it from violating the SSP? I know English has special circumstances with s regarding the SSP but I thought that was just with [st] and [sp] word initially.
-
also, forgot to add, but does 'slabs' violate it? – Emily Laycock Dec 16 '20 at 1:20
-
2Have you considered that by following your reasoning, almost every plural in English violates the principle? – LjL Dec 16 '20 at 2:44
-
Note that ax was standard for ask until about 1600 (though both forms existed in Old English, and the earlier root had -sk-). Also wasp, where both the -sp- and the -ps- form coexisted until recent times; in this case the Proto-Germanic had -ps-. – Colin Fine Dec 16 '20 at 23:08
The codas of six and slabs, [ks] and [bz], are in the order "stop-fricative", and in the sequence of features associated with sonority, fricatives are usually said to be more sonorous than stops (it's not the other way around). However, a third option is that stops and fricatives have the same sonority. Admittedly, a sonority plateau is not in conformity with the ideal of rising sonority for onsets and falling sonority for codas, but it's better than a sonority reversal. Notice that English also has [sp, st, sk] onsets but not *[ps,ts,ks]. At the very least, these coda clusters constitute a plateau, so are "outside" the reasoning about sonority and it's relationship to segment ordering.
The coda cluster /bz/ is not actually parallel to /ks/, since /bz/ is always polymorphemic, and the suffixes /-d, -z/ break the general rules regarding possible codas in English.
-
-z breaking coda rules is super interesting - do you happen to know of any articles that cover this? – Emily Laycock Dec 16 '20 at 1:53
-
In the Slavic languages before about 12th century AD every syllable was to comply with the Law of Increasing Sonority aka Law of Open Syllables, so the order of sounds in a syllable could be only like this and it couldn't be violated under no circumstances: fricative - stop (plosive or affricate) - nasal or [v] - liquid - vowel. As you can see, stops were considered more sonorous than fricatives. That's just for reference. – Yellow Sky Dec 18 '20 at 12:38