6

All the English speakers in this group are familiar with the use of "keep" to convey persistent action, whether the action is repeated (He kept knocking the ball off the table) or maintained (The ball kept rolling.)

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think that "keep" in this context is an aspectual auxiliary. But for the life of me, I can't find the name of the aspect that auxiliary "keep" conveys.

This Wikipedia article, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verbal_aspect#Lexical_vs._grammatical_aspect, names dozens of different aspects, but though it listed English aspects, it didn't contain an explicit referenced to auxiliary "keep".

So what's the name of the aspect that auxiliary "keep" conveys?

  • English might be traditionally biased to be thought of as an inflected language rather than an analytic language. So TAM categories built with syntax rather than inflection might not get equal attention. – hippietrail Jun 6 '13 at 4:25
  • It can go by a lot of different names, depending on what's being done (keep hammering might be "iterative", while keep sleeping might be continuative, for instance), as well as how many other aspectual terms there are to contrast with it. In some languages there'll be a lot, in others fewer. – jlawler Jun 6 '13 at 4:52
  • 1
    @jlawler: If this comment were officially an answer, I'd upvote it and check it. :) – James Grossmann Jun 8 '13 at 19:27
  • Thank you, but the answer's the important thing, after all. BTW, if you need more terminology, theres' more where those came from. Grammatical terms are almost all made from Latin (or occasionally Greek) words, and the etymology usually gives the meaning, since they're very conservative. – jlawler Jun 8 '13 at 20:27
  • @jlawler "keep hammering" is an interesting example, as now my brain wants to interpret the verb "hammer" as a frequentative and extrapolate some rule about keep+freq+ing. – Mark D Apr 4 '14 at 21:12
3

I think iterative fits best, although durative is another possibility. The verb keep can express iterative and/or durative aspect, meaning that it indicates the repetition of an event or action that persists. Iterative and durative are listed as an aspect in the Wikipedia article.

Looking at that article, however, the number of aspects that one needs to accommmodate all the various morphological and lexical mechanisms across languages that can express what we broadly construe as "aspect" is very large. My assessment is that the science in the area is not exact, nor can one expect it to be exact based on all the nuances. The grammarian therefore has a measure of freedom in the nomenclature he/she employs to denote the aspect at hand. The particular inventory of aspects posited is likely to vary from one grammarian to the next.

The situation is no different in other areas of grammar. The inventory of semantic roles (thematic roles) assumed varies from one grammarian to the next. The inventory of adjunct categories (causal, concessive, temporal, manner, etc.) also varies from one grammarian to the next. Why should it be any different for the inventory of aspects that the grammarian posits?

There is, however, a more concrete way to approach the classification of a verb like keep. It is not an auxiliary verb, since it does not license subject-auxiliary inversion or VP-ellipsis, nor does it accept not as a postdependent:

 a.  He kept laughing.
 b. *Kept he laughing?
 c. *She kept laughing, and he kept, too. 
 d. *He kept not laughing. 

Hence keep is unlike have of perfect aspect, which is a clearly an auxiliary. Keep is, rather, a subject-to-subject raising verb like begin (She began helping), quit (He quit eating), start (You started drinking), and stop (They stopped protesting). See the aticle on raising here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raising_%28linguistics%29. This class of raising verbs takes the progresssive participle as complement. Each of these verbs expresses aspect: begin and start express inchoative aspect, stop and quit terminative aspect. As a class, they might all be called aspectual (subject-to-suject) raising verbs.

In sum, keep is an aspectual (subject-to-subject) raising verb that expresses iterative/durative meaning.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.