1

It's an additional question to the following:

My understanding

What distinguishes aspirated/unaspirated is

voice onset time, the time between the release of the stop and the start of voicing,

where I understand voicing as the vibration of vocal cords. And unaspirated sounds have close-to-zero VOT and aspirated sounds greater VOT.

From the comments in the linked question, voiced/voiceless distinctions are done on the negative side of VOT. For simplicity (or by normalization), I assume VOT varies between -1 and 1. Then voiced sounds have VOT close to -1; and voiceless ones closer to zero (i.e., VOT greater than voiced ones by usual comparison).

Question

What is the difference of unaspirated and voiceless sounds? As I see in the link, there seem to exist languages that have three way distinctions. In such a language, I suppose the sound with VOT~-1 is called voiced and the sound with VOT~1 is called aspirated. What is the middle one called? Is it like the middle one is called voiceless if the distinction with the voiced sound is made within the negative side1 and called unaspirated otherwise?


1 I mean, if the language making the 3-way distinction distinguishes sounds of say, VOT(-1, -0.3) and VOT(-0.3, 0.1) and VOT(0.1, 1), where sounds whose VOT is between a and b are meant by VOT(a,b). Then -0.3 is the border which is negative, and VOT(-0.3, 0.1) is called voiceless.

3
  • Thai and Lao have such a distinction. I assume it's common across the Kra-Dai family. [+v;-v-a;+a] : [บ;ป;ผ/พ] [ด;ต;ท/ภ/ธ] and [ບ;ປ;ຜ/ພ] [ດ;ຕ;ຖທ] though for the 'k' series and 'tɕ' only have 2-way distinctions, lacking +v. (some Thai letters duplicating the same sounds omitted) Feb 12 at 10:02
  • @hippietrail Do you know how (e.g.) ป;ผ/พ are called? From what I checked, they seem to be unaspirated/aspirated pair and both voiceless. It this correct?
    – sundowner
    Feb 16 at 13:38
  • 1
    ป is unvoiced and unaspirated; ผ and พ are both unvoiced and aspirated. Those last two have the same sound but they have different effects on the tone of the syllable the commence. They do have Thai names which I don't know off the top of my head but would be easily Googleable. Feb 16 at 14:06

1 Answer 1

5

There may or may not be any difference!

As you say, both voicing and aspiration are extremes of voice onset time. Plenty of languages distinguish consonants based on VOT, and most of those languages have a binary contrast. Sounds with a VOT lower than a certain threshold are "lenis" (to avoid using the terms "voiceless" or "unaspirated" for the moment), and with a VOT higher than that threshold are "fortis".

Different languages put this threshold in different places. In Mandarin, it's very high, in Spanish, it's very low, and in English, it's somewhere in the middle. By convention, in Mandarin, we call the fortis consonants "aspirated" and the lenis consonants "unaspirated". In Spanish, we call the fortis consonants "voiceless", and the lenis consonants "voiced". In English, well…it depends who you ask!

In some other languages, like Ancient Greek, there's a three-way distinction in VOT. In these languages, we call the high-VOT one "aspirated", the low-VOT one "voiced", and the one in the middle alternately "voiceless", "unaspirated", "voiceless unaspirated", or just "tenuis".

So, what's the difference between "voiceless" and "unaspirated", acoustics-wise? Not much, necessarily! They both mean "closer to VOT 0". But what they contrast with is different.

(Also, VOT is normally a measure of time, measured in milliseconds or the like. So it's best to report the numbers directly rather than normalizing them.)

2
  • After this explanation I wonder how voiced aspirated stops like in Sanskrit work, but this is another question already asked here: linguistics.stackexchange.com/q/9443/9781 Feb 11 at 8:54
  • 1
    @SirCornflakes Sanskrit doesn't actually have voiced aspirated stops, so the answers to that question are not correct. The example I could find of true voiced aspirated was the Kelabit language spoken in Borneo - from my reading, the Kelabit voiced aspirates begin voiced and end voiceless.
    – Someone211
    Feb 11 at 11:58

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.