1

In English (and I believe in other languages, though I'm not certain), question words like "how" and "what" can be used as intensifiers, in phrases like

How beautiful

or

What splendor

or

What a beautiful child

Now, I can image analyzing the first as some kind of adverb, and the second as some kind of determiner--at the very least, they both both seem to be the same kind of thing as in the corresponding question phrases:

How big is she?

or

What apple do you want?

But I'm absolutely lost as to how to analyze "What a beautiful child"--can anyone help me out?

  • I think the usual term is exclamative adjective, though perhaps exclamativizer would be more appropriate. – StoneyB Apr 13 '14 at 0:39
  • Yes other languages (at least ones related to English) have this. Spanish: Que caballero! "What a gentleman!" German: Wie Schade. "What a pity." – hippietrail Apr 15 '14 at 10:46
3

I am not aware of literature that addresses the subject matter in the question directly. I have, however, thought about such cases quite a bit, and I have an unpublished paper that addresses some of the relevant data in part.

The interrogative word how is often a predependent of an adjective. It is asking for the relevant degree associated with the property expressed by the adjective, e.g. how big, how loud, how helpful, etc. These are relatively straightforward adjective phrases (APs), as pointed out in the question. I do not see anything mysterious or unusual about them.

Concerning examples with what, I think what often functions basically just like which, e.g. What apple do you have? = Which apple do you have?, What ideas is he promoting? = Which ideas is he promoting? In these examples, both what and which are functioning as interrogative determiners. On an NP analysis of noun phrases, they are predependents of the nouns that they introduce.

But the analysis of examples like what a beautiful child are indeed more challenging. They are challenging because it appears as though the noun child takes two determiners, what and a. This seems to be a particular idiosyncracy of what. Other interrogative determiners are incapable of doing the same, e.g. *Which a beautiful child.

However, English has a construction that seems related, e.g.

 how big (of) a fool

 too crazy (of) a man

 that bold (of) a move

In these cases, the preposition of appears optionally. With what, the preposition of cannot appear, e.g. *what of a beautiful child. Furthermore, the indefinite article is obligatory in such cases. With what, the indefinite article need not appear, e.g.

 what beautiful children

            vs.

 *how big (of) fools

 *too crazy (of) men

 *that bold (of) the move

These examples further illustrate that the ability of what to appear in NPs such as what a beautiful child is an idiosyncracy of what. One analysis of the construction might view what as a nominal that takes an indefinite NP as its complement: [what [a beautiful child]].

Finally, the following data can be construed as involving a type of ellipsis:

 How crazy (she is)!

 What a beautiful child (she is)!

 What fun (that was)!

 How entertaining (that is)!

The ellipsis mechanism optionally elides a definite pronoun and a form of the copula. This mechanism shows up in other constructions, e.g. If (you are) interested, you should contact me. I call this ellipsis mechanism slicing. I will share my unpublished manuscript on slicing if anyone is interested. I can be contacted via my email; my address is on my Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Tjo3ya.

  • Hi Tim. I'd be interested in seeing your manuscript, if you wouldn't mind sending it along (my email add. is on my profile page). I like 'slicing' - very Ross-esque. – P Elliott Apr 13 '14 at 15:51
  • @P Elliott, thanks for your interest. I just sent the manuscript to the email address on your bio page. I see you have worked on island repair. Concerning any feedback you might have on the manuscript, I'd certainly like to see it. – Tim Osborne Apr 13 '14 at 17:44

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.