73
votes
Accepted
Is Sanskrit really the mother of all languages?
No, it is not.
First and foremost, there are many languages recorded long before the advent of Sanskrit, and many religions recorded long before the advent of Hinduism. The oldest surviving texts in ...
- 62.2k
31
votes
Is Sanskrit really the mother of all languages?
Sanskrit is not the mother of all languages. Sanskrit is not even the mother of the modern Indo-Aryan languages of the Northern India. Neither it is their father or grandfather. In fact, no language ...
- 17.6k
12
votes
Is there any language which doesn't have "hello", "thank you" or "please"?
The only language that has "hello", "please" and "thank you" is English. Other languages might have other words that they use in somewhat similar circumstances, but I don't think any language has an ...
- 80.3k
10
votes
Is Sanskrit really the mother of all languages?
Not at all.
Sanskrit, Latin and a few other languages had a common ancestor called Proto-Indo-European, which was prevalent around 2500 BC on the southern steppes of Russia.
It is a fact that ...
- 363
10
votes
Could you point out some theories on how the names for numbers developed?
The following theories that try to explain the origin of Proto-Indo-European numerals are mentioned in J. P. Mallory, D. Q. Adams, The Oxford Introduction to Proto-Indo-European and the Proto-Indo-...
- 895
10
votes
Accepted
Was language invented only once or several times?
The question raises three terminological issues: what is "language", what is "invented" and what is "once"? It does presuppose that there was a prior state without language, and a later state with it (...
- 80.3k
9
votes
How would someone begin translating an unknown language?
Take a look at John Chadwick's The Decipherment of Linear B. It does include some relevant theory -- I've used it as a text in an elementary linguistics course.
- 12.4k
8
votes
Accepted
Is agnosticism the current orthodoxy regarding linguistic macrofamilies?
I think the prior question should be, who gets to vote? The difference between agnosticism and dogmatic nihilism, as I interpret the concepts, is that the agnostician simply says "I don't know", and ...
- 80.3k
8
votes
What is the essence of the dispute between Wolfe and Chomsky?
It's complex at first but there's very little controversy to be found.
Noam Chomsky is a linguist and political activist famous for revolutionizing the study of all areas of linguistics via ...
- 4,445
7
votes
What is the essence of the dispute between Wolfe and Chomsky?
Chomsky's argument for the Universal Grammar:
Children pick up language quickly because of a Language Acquisition Device (LAD).
While the LAD is hypothetical, Chomsky believes it to be innate and a ...
- 584
5
votes
How would someone begin translating an unknown language?
Your question is closely related to Bootstrapping, a process in which children initiate the language acquisition. Therefore, in addition to knowledge how scientists decipher the unknown language, ...
- 8,557
5
votes
How would someone begin translating an unknown language?
My answer is just an addition to Greg Lee's answer here. John Chadwick popularized how Michael Ventris and he deciphered Linear B, but the first right steps to the decipherment were made by Alice ...
- 151
4
votes
Are some languages more advanced than others?
If you mean full-blown natural languages, the answer is negative unless you introduce a notion of advanceness which will handicap some languages with respect to others (e.g. by setting (the length of) ...
- 494
4
votes
Are some languages more advanced than others?
Some languages make it more difficult (impractical, though maybe not impossible) to express some concepts.
For example, most European languages have a wide range of tenses for verbs, including ...
- 149
4
votes
Accepted
Why does Latin, Turkish, and Albanian share common words?
There are three possible explanations:
Turkish has borrowed many words from other languages, just as has Albanian. I have been told courant d'air is actually a Turkish word (probably spelled the ...
- 7,956
3
votes
Has the current opinion of linguists about the earliest language been influence by ethology?
Linguists are pretty much unpersuaded by dubious claims about parrots and dogs "having language" in some sense. However, there is an actual albeit small influence from evolutionary biology ...
- 80.3k
3
votes
Was language invented only once or several times?
Well, it happens even nowadays that languages are created anew from fragments of other languages.
There are creoles like Papiamento or Tok Pisin that are created from fragments of different and ...
- 29.5k
3
votes
Onomatopoeia origin of language?
Modern research on the origin of language focuses on how the "computational capacity of the mind" to process syntax could have arisen. In that sense, whether the first sounds were ...
- 530
3
votes
Accepted
What is motivatedness?
In the context of sound-symbolism and indeed the semiotic theories that are discussed in the article, a sign (linguistic or otherwise) is said to be motivated or iconic if its signifier has something ...
- 1,023
3
votes
How would someone begin translating an unknown language?
Hopefully you can revise your question:
Are there clues as to how old the language is?
Does the language use a known alphabet (or have any hints of parentage)?
Are their contextual samples (signs or ...
- 656
3
votes
Did Proto-Sino-Tibetan and Proto-Indo-European languages have the same origin?
The interesting question here is whether humans developed a common language prior to migration from Africa. This is not a linguistic question in the strict sense, it is a question of human evolution ...
- 80.3k
2
votes
Is it possible to detect onomatopoeic basis in indigenous languages?
Max Müller started the tradition of giving such silly names to theories of language origin in his 1861 Lectures on the Science of Language, which is available on line and which I recommend to you.
...
- 12.4k
2
votes
What is the essence of the dispute between Wolfe and Chomsky?
Here is my summary (drawn from reviews of Wolfe's book -- I didn't read it). A correct view of this question about the nature of language would have to emerge from exposure to facts in the field. ...
- 12.4k
2
votes
Accepted
What is the origins of this language from the Circassian family?
I'm curious how you know what Sumerian sounded like, or what the extinct Semitic languages sound like. It does not sound like Modern Hebrew, nor in my opinion like Arabic or Tigre (Ethiopian Semitic). ...
- 80.3k
1
vote
Why does Latin, Turkish, and Albanian share common words?
A slightly more specific answer:
Albanian and Latin are both Indo-European languages and share a fair number of inherited words, especially in the core vocabulary (e.g. numerals).
.Albania was part ...
- 23.7k
1
vote
Could you point out some theories on how the names for numbers developed?
This might not be directly what you were looking for, but if you're interested in the "names" for numerals, one thing I think might be valid is the point of "discrimination", i.e. because the numbers ...
- 593
1
vote
Difference between languages related a long time ago and unrelated ones
There are methods for calculating the age of the split between two languages (which, conveniently, I do not rembember the details of). They rely on counting related material versus unrelated material, ...
- 1,763
1
vote
Is it possible to detect onomatopoeic basis in indigenous languages?
@Probably, by the looks of it, you are in for a lot of primary research, though, I'd suggest you consider flipping it upside down, for the following reasons:
I would like to make a poll with ...
- 563
1
vote
Is there any language which doesn't have "hello", "thank you" or "please"?
This is really a question at the intersection of language and culture. It has nothing to do with proto-language or much to do with language as such. When you ask for words for 'hello' or 'thank you', ...
- 10.6k
Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible